The defense has rested its case in the Karmelo Anthony murder trial.
Closing arguments are scheduled for Tuesday morning after testimony ends without the defendant, who claims he stabbed Austin Metcalf in self-defense at a Frisco Independent School District track meet last year, taking the stand.
Defense rests without Anthony taking the stand
The defense presented only three witnesses before resting on Monday. There was a lengthy break stretching from late morning to mid-afternoon, where many wondered whether Anthony would testify.
In the end, he and his attorneys chose not to have him speak directly to a jury that will begin deciding his fate on Tuesday.
Four days of testimony in the murder trial ended with two high school track athletes testifying about what they saw on the day Austin Metcalf was stabbed to death in a Frisco stadium.
They both backed up defense claims that Anthony’s decision to enter the Memorial High School tent was normal.
DEFENSE: How is the culture around a track meet different than a football game?
WITNESS: They’re really social, so everybody would know each other, see each other, say hi…really social.
DEFENSE: Is that only on the field, only in the bleachers? How would you describe it?
WITNESS: It’s all over the place.
Video evidence challenges witness accounts
One of them told police they saw a punch, which contradicts more than a dozen prosecution witnesses.
DEFENSE: Did anything happen that you took particular notice of in the stands?
WITNESS: Everybody was standing up and I saw somebody get pushed or get punched, I don’t know which.
But under cross-examination, prosecutors show the jury a video that captured the witness on the field stretching and not even looking in the stands until after the stabbing.
PROSECUTION: A lot of what you said, you’re kind of guessing?
WITNESS: Yes, sir.
PROSECUTION: Do you remember seeing the video i showed you?
WITNESS: Yes, sir.
PROSECUTION: It showed that you didn’t see what you thought you saw?
WITNESS: Yes, sir.
The other witness:
DEFENSE: Do you remember telling the detective My teammate might be in trouble and maybe I needed to go help him’?
WITNESS: Yes, sir, I thought there could be something wrong. I wanted my teammates to see it too.
DEFENSE: What did you see when you first noticed something was wrong?
WITNESS: I saw the arms go out. I see arms and make contact with Karmelo.
But that witness also recanted when prosecutors showed him the video of what happened.
PROSECUTION: And when you saw the video, your eyes were opened to what actually happened, is that right?
WITNESS: Yes
PROSEUCTION: My impression, when we first met, you thought when you saw people surrounding Karmelo Anthony. It was before the stabbing?
WITNESS: Yes, sir.
PROSEUCTION: That was actually after the stabbing?
WITNESS: I couldn’t really tell.
Closing arguments set for Tuesday
It’s anybody’s guess how the jury will react to this testimony and the state’s case.
The jury is not allowed to hold it against Anthony that he chose not to testify.
With closing arguments beginning at 9 a.m., it’s likely the jury will start deliberating sometime around noon.
We don’t know at this point whether or not the jury can consider other charges than murder, which carries a sentence of 5 to 99 years in prison.
News
If She Gets Out: Mackenzie Shirilla has allegedly made careful plans for life beyond pr!son despite uncertainty about her future
At her sentencing, Mackenzie Shirilla was told there’s a high change she will never leave prison. In a scathing vote of no confidence, the judge said she didn’t feel it necessary to give Shirilla the highest term available, because she didn’t ever think she would be granted parole. This moment was shown in The Crash […]
Heartbreaking Words: “My son isn’t here anymore because a boy got angry,” Austin Metcalf’s mother said through tears in a newly released video
“Just because the kid was mad, my son is not here anymore and I don’t understand it.” — Meghan Metcalf, mother of slain high school student Austin Metcalf A high school student has been charged with murder in the fatal stabbing of another student at a track meet in Texas, police said. The incident occurred […]
“My son is gone because a boy got angry, and I still don’t understand why”: Austin Metcalf’s mother broke down in tears in a new video released by her husband
“Just because the kid was mad, my son is not here anymore and I don’t understand it.” — Meghan Metcalf, mother of slain high school student Austin Metcalf A high school student has been charged with murder in the fatal stabbing of another student at a track meet in Texas, police said. The incident occurred […]
Teammate Testimony: A teammate said Karmelo Anthony appeared “panicked” immediately after Austin Metcalf was k!lled and kept making the same gesture in the crowd
Texas teen Karmelo Anthony appeared “distraught” in the moments after he allegedly fatally stabbed Austin Metcalf, another student testified Monday at his murder trial. A 17-year-old teammate of Anthony described the “chaos” that ensued at a track and field meet in Frisco on April 2, 2025 after Anthony and Metcalf got into a dispute over […]
Day 6 Trial Update: Karmelo Anthony took the stand and began an emotional, tear-filled defense before the court
MCKINNEY, Texas – A Texas jury will soon decide the fate of Karmelo Anthony. Anthony, 19, has been charged with murder in connection with the stabbing death of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf. Investigators said Anthony and Metcalf got into an argument over stadium seating during a track meet in Frisco on April 2, 2025. When the disagreement […]
Courtroom Live: The Karmelo Anthony murder trial continues today as new testimony emerges in the Austin Metcalf case
The Karmelo Anthony trial continued Saturday for almost nine hours with about a dozen witnesses at the Collin County Courthouse. Many of them broke down in tears while testifying. Anthony is charged with the stabbing death of 17-year-old Austin Metcalf at a Frisco track meet in April 2025. The prosecution rested after calling 21 witnesses. […]
End of content
No more pages to load












